There are many debates on the value of a college degree but three points seems to be a recurrent source of debate, and that is cost, personal satisfaction, and employment reassurance.
Both Ungar and Wilson talked about cost in different lights. Ungar believes that the benefits of receiving a liberal arts degree out weighs the cons of the financial debt that a person may have after college. He believes that the degree that one receives from a liberal arts education is valuable for a changing complex world. Wilson explains that even though college debt is higher now that it once was, that the astronomical college debt numbers that gets attention is only an outliers. The average college debt she says is a much smaller number that what is portrayed by the media.
The second point of controversy is the personal satisfaction a person might receive from attending college. On this topic Murray believes that only people who scored in the top percentile of the ACT are capable of enjoying and meeting the demand of the rigor of a liberal arts program. With that said he also believes only those people should attend college because they are capable of providing a higher service to society with their ability. Wilson would disagree with this because he believes everyone should have the opportunity to reap the benefits of a liberal arts degree and with the skills they derived will make them a better person and at the same time society would be improved. Wilson also says sometimes the person have no background on a topic can provide a unique outlook and are usually quick to catch up.
The final point of debate is the ability a college degree has for job assurance. Murray is displeased with employers using a college degree as an hiring check mark. He says that a person who may not have a degree but is able to do the work better would get pass over. Wilson feels that a liberal arts degree would prepare a person to take on any challenges that a career my presents.
These points are important because they are factors that helps a person determines whether or not they want to go to college. The ability to pay for a college degree is important is important to many people. Many do not want to have massive debt after school. People want comfort in knowing that after the four years or more they dedicate for a degree they will be able to find a job afterwards. Personal satisfaction is also important because a person may think they are better off getting real life experience instead of siting in a class room.